Personal Review From Customer (Unbiased)
May 5 people found the following review helpful.
All things considered ... More mixed blessing
By Diane B. Wilkes
I am a devout Janeite, and although I'm not a purist, I'm very selective when it comes to Austen sequels and variants. I recognize that there are (relative) and classic dishes in the times set in the regency and more modern settings, but I am always prefer the updated version to contemporary accounts and review period. I suspect it's because there is less of a direct comparison with Austen's original work - and no one benefits from life of this comparison in the eyes and heart an amateur.
In Jane Austen BESPELLING, one has two novels each time ... the twist of paranormal activity in each story enthreaded. Mary Balogh, a writer of Regency romance of great reputation, returns persuasion of Anne Elliot in time, but change the name of Jane (!) Everett. Captain Wentworth has also been renamed (Captain Mitford). Using his reincarnation as "supernatural" device, and Captain Jane Mitford would have liked, but lost each other again and again in their lifetimes, but decide not to do so this time. Jane is "almost certain" (the name of the novel Balogh), but ...
Colleen Gleason (Gardella series which has made me a devoted fan) updates Northanger Abbey Northanger CASTILLO. I think I reviewed one of Thorpe in a vampire's perfect casting - I just wish I had chosen another Thorpe. But then both are bloodsuckers innate, so it works very well. I will not say what the profession Thaddeus Blanchard (Henry Tilney ne) has taken, but it is related to Victoria Gardella. Catherine Morland is now Caroline Merrill, and although both have a taste for reading of Gothic novels and have wild imagination, Caroline is braver and more observers in many ways. She deserves her partner! While there are one or two references to the series Gardella, you should have no problem following this story, even if you've never read any of them.
The last two novels (the modernized) are written in first person, unlike the third person to the first two are written in. This enhances and promotes a feeling of freshness and modernity. BLOOD AND PREJUDICE is quite faithful to the original names of the characters P & P and the first page we learn that works on the books Lizzy of Longbourn. How perfect is that? The author, Susan Krinard, is faithful to Austen's innate values as well - that is, if Darcy had written Austen as a vampire. I think Krinard more faithful to Austen's vampire tradition, and that is my preference as well.
I was surprised that my favorite of these four is EMMA, updated as little hex her, Janet Mullany. She is so faithful to Emma Krinard is P & P, though she also had the names of most characters (Miss Bates is Missy Bates, however). Emma Woodhouse This runs a dating service in Washington, DC (again, the perfect occupation!) The magic - Naiads, witches, vampires and werewolves, for example. George Knightley works in high finance and the owner of the building in which Emma lives, but dates from college, but Emma broke up with him shortly after making love for the first time. It is very Jane Austen. However, although not as faithful to the structure, Mullany really get the spirit of Jane Austen but modernizing the situation so that I could appreciate as a stand-alone, without constantly thinking about the original. And interestingly, I think it works best of all for me in this particular genre.
As I thought of this review, I discovered something about my preferences: I really prefer the novels of long novels. You can not have wonderful character development that takes place in any of the novels of Jane Austen, Northanger Abbey, but in 100 pages or less.
One last note: often, a book with four different authors, you feel there is a weak link. I did not feel that way with BESPELLING Jane Austen. Perhaps the author was a charm, too.
More Bespelling Jane Austen: Almost Persuaded\Northanger Castle\Blood and Prejudice\Little to Hex Her [Paperback] reviews available
Read more..
Buy Cheap Bespelling Jane Austen: Almost Persuaded\Northanger Castle\Blood and Prejudice\Little to Hex Her [Paperback] - Sale price!
Product Details
- Amazon Sales Rank: # 304,356 in Books
- Posted: 09/28/2010
- Posted: 28/09/2010
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Binding: Paperback
- 384 pages
Features
- ISBN13: 9780373775019
- Status:
- Notes: NEW EDITOR! 100% satisfaction guarantee. Always follow up on most orders. Buy with confidence! Million books sold!

0 comments:
Post a Comment